Scoring Tool

Step 1 of 13

Score Sheet for Region IV COT Trauma Paper Competition

Please note that in the category of originality and individual work, it should be clarified that residents submitting clinical papers have done most of the data collection in person, rather than performing analyses of data collected by others.

Scores can be given in half points (2.5, 3.5, etc). The basic rule of thumb is 1 = poor, 3 = good, 5= excellent

All scorers should score all presentations, regardless of resident affiliation.

Reviewer Name(Required)

First Last

Brooke Davis, MD
Clinical
To Scan or not to Scan-The value of postop CT after craniotomy in TBI patients

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Jaclyn Portelli Tremont, MD
Clinical
WakeMed Health & Hospitals Low Health Literacy Is Associated with Inferior Outcomes in a Diverse Trauma Population

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Christopher Reed, MD
Basic Science
Duke University Medical Center Prospective Study of Intrinsic Versus Tissue Factor-Mediated Coagulopathies In Pediatric Trauma

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Lauren Kelly, MD
Basic Science
Absense of hepcidin prevents erythroid progenitor suppression in a rodent model of trauma-hemorrhage

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

William Risinger
Clinical
A New Pandemic and an Old Epidemic – The Impact of COVID-19 and Gun Violence as Measured by Years of Potential Life Lost in a US City

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Will Hudson
Clinical
Atlanta Medical Center, PGY-3 resident Reduction of Opioid Use in Trauma: A Multimodal Approach

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Eric Forney
Clinical
Navicent Do all Isolated Traumatic SAH need to be Transferred to a Level I Trauma Center?

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Victoria Miles
Clinical
UT Chattanooga, surgery resident Platelet Dysfunction in TBI: Characterization and the Utility of Platelet Transfusion to Treat

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Michael Tichenor
Clinical
Comparison of post-operative morphine milligram equivalents used between intrapleural and extrapleural systems for surgical stabilization of rib fractures

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Peter Abraham
Clinical
UAB Provider Perspectives on the Role of CPR in Traumatic Cardiac Arrest

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Emily Green
Basic Science
UMMC Orthopedic injury induces release of cell-free nuclear and mitochondrial DNA: A rodent model

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments

Taylor Shaw
Clinical
UMMC Population density and triage of pediatric firearm injuries in a rural statewide trauma system: A single center cohort study

Paper Quality (maximum score = 5)

Presentation Quality (maximum score = 5)

Scientific Merit (maximum score = 5)

Relevance and Importance (maximum score = 5)

Originality and Individual Work (maximum score = 5)

Question Response (maximum score = 5)

Total Score (maximum score = 30)

Comments